I’ve always felt strongly that teaching is my calling. As I embark upon my final year here on the Hill, I feel overwhelmed by the multitude of possibilities that await me upon my graduation in May. Rewind to my first year at Holy Cross, I was (and am) a student who was very passionate about becoming involved the field of Education and excited to leave my mark. Teaching, for me, has always been the end goal.
Teaching is not a stepping stone into the “real world,” nor is it something I’m willing to “try out” for a number of years after graduating only to later throw away. That’s why, when my eager peers are excited to inform me that they’re applying to Teach for America, I will always have a hard time smiling and biting my tongue.
Founded in 1990, Teach for America guarantees recent graduates an opportunity to do just that: briefly encounter the teaching profession within the context of a high need institution only to leave it behind two years later. A nonprofit organization which seeks to “enlist, develop, and mobilize as many as possible of our nation’s most promising future leaders to grow and strengthen the movement for educational equity and excellence,” TFA undermines the value of an intensive undergraduate Teacher Education Program. Teach for America’s “intensive summer training program” takes participants through the very basics of what it means to be a teacher. Although it is undeniable that the diverse nature of the corps itself, which is constituted by graduates holding degrees in a myriad of disciplines, may very well bring new perspectives to schools that are in need of resources, I refuse to believe that we are doing the schools in which we place them much justice.
The fact that these highly undertrained “teachers” are being placed in extraordinarily high need schools that desperately need experienced veteran educators is a travesty. Daniel Katz, Director of Secondary Education and Secondary Special Education Teacher Preparation at Seton Hall University, articulates that, because his students “all intend to stay classroom teachers,” pursuing an opportunity with TFA upon receiving their undergraduate degree is a waste. “This isn’t something they suddenly decided to do,” Katz continues.
“This isn’t a means for them to ‘give back’ on their way to something else. This is a career they have been thinking about since they were much younger and to which they have dedicated their entire time in college to entering.”
If our ultimate goal is to benefit our students and provide them with a quality education, why, then, would we place individuals with little to absolutely no experience who are often simply looking for something to do after college graduation in schools that are desperate for resources? This denigrates our profession and leaves our students in need of teachers who are inspired to commit their lives to teaching. I myself am one of those individuals. Teaching, for me, has always been the end goal. Teaching is not, by any means, a step along way; it is profession to which I will dedicate the rest my life and remain passionate about so long as I live.